Posts Tagged Constitution

Why did FDR bully the Supreme Court in his attempt to circumvent the Constitution?

Question by O-baa-ma: Why did FDR bully the Supreme Court in his attempt to circumvent the Constitution?
“They had been piecing together bits of constitutional law and precedent in order to determine what Roosevelt could have done to modify the court systems. They came upon four different ideas, all with their merits and disadvantages. The first option was to amend the Constitution in order to give expanded powers to the federal government, circumventing the repeated roadblocks to national recovery. Another option was to limit the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, as well as the lower courts, to hear certain cases. A third option was to require more than a simple majority to decide a case, eliminating swing votes and reflecting a more definitive vision of the Constitution. The final option was termed “court packing,” or placing more justices on the Court. “Packing” the judiciary required assigning a new junior justice to the Court when a current justice was not able to complete their duties. The “court packing” plan would rise above the other options as the winner in the reorganization derby but would face a long struggle.”

“Instead of a portion of the government or a secondary player, the Supreme Court was now seen as the enemy of progress, as a political player…”

http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/20202/fdr_and_the_supreme_court_pg7.html?cat=37

Why is the man who forced the Supreme Court to “interpret” the Constitution in the interest of his ideology considered a great President?

Don’t the results of his actions suggest he should be considered one of the worst Presidents?
Leopold-
Because the people follow and believe in and vote for you doesn’t make you great.

Best answer:

Answer by Libs lost Power! SWEET!
Because FDR was a sucky president! He did! He was aweful! He did nothing good for the economy- grew govt and was a socialist.

What do you think? Answer below!

  • Share/Bookmark

, , , , ,

6 Comments

Since the Constitution specifies that policing power is to be left only to States, why have federal drug laws?

Question by Anti_Censorship: Since the Constitution specifies that policing power is to be left only to States, why have federal drug laws?
During the birth of the US Constitution, it was understood that people had the right to do what they wanted with their own minds and bodies. Why do we now have federal drug laws against marijuana which puts more “offenders” into prisions wasting taxpayer money? Do we really want the government making personal decisions for us?
People smoking marijuana privately in their own homes without causing a problem does not constitute anything close to interstate commerce.

Best answer:

Answer by Andy J
no… vote Ron Paul

they make so much money catching people who do drugs, fines, fees, all sorts of crazy cash. the department of trasnportation is in on it too

Know better? Leave your own answer in the comments!

  • Share/Bookmark

, , , , , , , , , ,

6 Comments

Q&A: Are drug laws even legal according to the Constitution?

Question by heaven35: Are drug laws even legal according to the Constitution?
I know there laws against drug but do you think our founding fathers would agree to them,or no?Also what do you think our laws on drugs will be like when our generation get older,and the baby boomer goes into retirement?Please give me your personal opinion on drugs laws,and where the constitution stands on them.I don`t do drugs,nor will i ever try but it still suppose to be free country right?Drugs are bad but still.

Best answer:

Answer by Señor Sñarky
A free country doesn’t mean that you have the right to do whatever you want. It’s a republic so we elect representatives to make laws for us that represent our values. Somewhere along the line our representatives decided that drugs were bad and that’s what the majority of Americans apparently agree with because the laws haven’t been taken down and there hasn’t been a major push to remove them (present efforts for marijuana excluded).

What do you think? Answer below!

  • Share/Bookmark

, , , , ,

2 Comments